Fast answer
For a first Cinque Terre stay, start with the daily friction before choosing the village that looks best in photos. Monterosso is the most forgiving village choice when beach access, arrival, and movement matter. Vernazza and Manarola are stronger for atmosphere but ask more from crowds, stairs, luggage, and access checks. Corniglia is quieter and more removed, with the station below the village and no normal ferry role. Riomaggiore fits the southern end and Via dell'Amore context. Choose Levanto or La Spezia when the trip needs easier logistics more than sleeping inside the villages.
If you only do one thing
Default to Monterosso if you want to sleep inside Cinque Terre but still reduce friction. Choose Vernazza or Manarola when atmosphere matters enough to accept tighter logistics, Corniglia only if station-to-village movement and no ferry access are acceptable, Riomaggiore when the southern end shapes the plan, Levanto for a softer northern base, and La Spezia when rail practicality, luggage, or price pressure matters most.
Compare relevant booking options